This one is for Al-Nakba. Written a few days ago …
Three years ago, I was still in the closet. About being pro Palestine.
I knew I was. I knew it ever since I went to that Nakba rally when I was 16 years old. Everyone looked like me and my family. I had never seen anyone who looked like me outside of my family, and had always thought that I was secretly hispanic since everyone in California responded to my hair not being blonde by speaking Spanish.
I switched the language I was taking in college from Spanish to Arabic. I bought a bottle of olive oil. I learned what Palestine was, and that people could be Palestinian, and that these peoples’ families had been displaced from their homes.
I learned that they ate the same food that my Lebanese family ate, cooked with the same spices, and that the women had the same out of control hair. They were also Arab, without being Muslim. They were me, I was them, we were one: I’m Lebanese, but hell, its culturally inseparable from being Palestinian.
That’s when the conflict got personal.
I was told that I could offend people by talking about Palestine. I didn’t understand this, because it seemed like the most just, worthy cause that I had ever heard of. I was willing to defend it to its very core.
I went to NYU for college. Everyone was Jewish.
I was trying to make friends, and everyone I talked to was Jewish. I felt silenced, I felt like I could not talk about what I was most passionate about. I skirted around the issue, skirted around my family’s background, and skirted around the reasons that I was taking Arabic. I was nervous, and whenever I dared to discuss it —dared to let it be known that I was pro Palestine —I was immediately shut down.
“But Hamas are terrorists! They send rockets into Israel! That could kill someone!”
Well, Israel fucking did kill someone. That winter, they killed 1400 in Operation Cast Lead.
I started to realize that my opinions were controversial, but they were justified. I had even convinced myself that I was some kind of terrorist for wanting justice for Palestinians, even though I never have even said to myself that I want a complete end to Israel. For the first time, I felt like a good person for wanting justice.
I still felt silenced on campus. I still felt silenced by my peers. I still felt silenced (and outraged) when my neighbor, a frat brother in a Jewish frat and his friends knocked on my door to advertise their fundraiser for the IDF. I still felt silenced by my outspoken Jewish friends, and tried to go along with it and ask them about their culture without talking about the “I” word or their birthright trips.
Most of all, I hated when people would try to debate the Israeli Palestinian conflict as an issue. It’s not a fucking debate. It’s peoples lives.
I hated when people told me to calm down, and that Barack Obama was negotiating a peace process. I hated the people who said that both sides had done wrong and then avoided talking about it. This is oppression and power dynamics, not some playground battle.
My second year of college, I put a “Palestine” pin on my purse. This felt like a controversial act. I got more hatred from the Jewish frat boys in Campus, more questions about BDS, more accusations of being stupid and advocating for terrorists. I found Students for Justice in Palestine. I found Adalah NY. I found GRITtv. I bought a kuffiyeh and put it across my bed. I wasn’t alone anymore.
The tragedies — but also the successes of the Freedom Flotilla and the Mavi Marmara happened that June (technically May), and suddenly the green, black, white, and red flag that I held so close to my heart was sprawled across newspapers and websites. People in the “both sides have committed wrongs” crowd came out for Palestine. The protests were amazing.
I got to start writing about Palestine issues and am now somewhere in the New York Times’ photo repetoire of “angry Arab-American girl holding a Palestinian flag.”
I lived in Paris for a semester, got involved in other issues, and came back to the United States discombobulated, and upset that I was no longer in a country that valued protests and revolutions as a unique part of its history. I read the news exclusively in French, where two words absent from American Papers – “Sidi Bouzid” became an increasingly prevalent issue. I remember telling my mother, “I think this Tunisia thing is going to be huge —but its nowhere in American papers.”
Then it happened. Then Egypt happened. Then the protests looked a whole lot less like someone’s entire Arab extended family decided to come out, and a whole lot more like genuine solidarity. People woke up. Arabs were no longer the demons behind Al Qaeda and September 11th. They were no longer the misogynists who did not allow women to drive and made women cover completely. They were people —people who were infinitely braver than us and willing to risk arrest and death for freedom.
Now, we are back to Palestine. Back to the Nakba, and almost at the anniversary of the Freedom Flotilla. Genuine change has happened. Fatah and Hamas, the two notorious rival political factions agreed to set aside their differences and unite against the Israeli Occupation. Egypt has opened its border with Gaza. There is no more Mubarak to arrest foreign aid convoys. There might be genuine change.
Today is Israeli Independence Day, it is almost Al Nakba. There are signs around Washington Square Park for free falafel. It now seems silly —I no longer feel threatened.